In a recent article, researchers from Stanford University found that the struggle with racism excels after the second Black student infraction and resulting in harsher consequences for Black students. The perception that White teachers have regarding Black students is very different from the perception that White teachers have regarding White students. Reducing the struggle with racism will require that teachers and administrators better understand the verbal communication differences between White teachers and Black students.
These records described two instances of misbehaviour by a student. The teachers were asked about their perception of the severity, how irritated that misbehaviour would make them and how the student should be punished.
Do cultural debating expectation differences contribute to the schools struggle with racism?
Cultural differences can affect teacher-student classroom relationships when debates occur in the classroom. For Whites, the purpose of an argument is to ventilate anger and hostility. Black students are taught to distinguish between an argument used to debate a difference of opinion and an argument used to ventilate anger and hostility.
Whites misinterpret Black intentions to solve a disagreement and do not believe Blacks who want to solve a disagreement. A request from a Black student to a White teacher may be construed as a demand.
Blacks communicate in debates by becoming high-keyed, animated, interpersonal, and confrontational while middle-class Whites communicate in debates by becoming low-keyed, dispassionate, impersonal, and non-challenging. The differences in Black and White debating behaviors can cause classroom arguments that escalated to harsher discipline for Black students.
Some in-class arguments between teachers and Black students are a product of the Blacks system of language socialization that involves students talking, which gets others in the group to listen and respond. Black students are inclined to talk back when motivated by what a teacher says. Black students may become so impressed with the speaker, such as a teacher, that students will want to hear the speaker again due to an interest in how it was said.
Black students also exhibit affective classroom behavior that can influence positive teacher-student classroom relationships. Urban Black students want to create the appropriate mood and setting before beginning to work on a task by asking the teacher to repeat the directions. Blacks will argue for recognition of unsuccessful efforts toward completing a task while many teachers do not expect Black students to interrupt the class by talking to their neighbors and speak without raising their hands.
Educators assume quiet students are successful and receive rewards for making teaching an easier task. Teachers respond to students talking in the classroom without permission by ordering, reprimanding, involving students in work, and naming the student. When a teacher yells, uses harsh words, shames, degrades, or embarrasses a student, such behavior influences all students.
Teachers who use coercion, an attempt to manage students by applying sanctions such as detention, suspension, and corporal punishment, are ineffective when working with resistant students. Resistant students view this as the boss using coercion and become the teacher’s adversaries.
Teachers can offset the negative outcomes associated with verbal communication problems by:
- Talking to students at the end of the week regarding some shared topic or at the end of a unit
- Talking to students when they are working on assignments
- Commenting in a positive and affirming manner
- Talking to students at the beginning and end of the school week
Dr. Derrick L. Campbell, Ed.D.
PO Box 1668 Blackwood, NJ 08012
Get Email Updates
Author of Promoting Positive Racial Teacher Student Classroom Relationships
“The model that you use to analyze teacher-student relationships is a good one for most school districts”.
~ Joe Vas ~ Perth Amboy Mayor
“Dr. Campbell’s Cultural Relationship Training Program is comprehensive, informative, and should be required training for all schools”
~ Darrell Pope ~ Hutchinson Kansas NAACP President